Comics vs. Cinema: V for Vendetta

Premise: A totalitarian British government is menaced by a brutal vigilante with a flair for the theatric.

I saw V For Vendetta a couple of nights ago. It was a mostly-faithful adaptation of the comic, and possibly the most courageous film to come from a major Hollywood studio in recent years. Hugo Weaving is the perfect choice to play V, and manages to convey emotions while wearing a full face mask that never changes expression. Natalie Portman is pretty good as Evey, although she did have a little trouble maintaining the English accent. Stephen Rea gives what is sure to be an underrated performance as Inspector Finch, who, for good or for ill, uncovers the truth about V. The Wachowski Brothers did find places to add their signature brand of action, with mixed results.

I had originally planned to discuss the changes in greater detail, but after re-reading (okay, skimming) the graphic novel, I believe that most of the changes were cosmetic. The comic is a work of greater subtlety than the film, but, as a work of fiction serialized over the course of a decade, it can afford to be. Also, the central characters were made more sympathetic than they appear in the original comic. In Alan Moore and David Lloyd's original story, V was even more ruthless, Evey was an underage prostitute, and Finch's obsession with finding V put tremendous strain on his marriage. Finally, Moore's original comic was a commentary on Thatcher's Britain, and while there are similarities between what happened there in the 80's and what is happening in America now, some changes were necessary for the work to maintain relevance.

Recommended For: people who thought the movie felt a little rushed; people dissatisfied with the Bush Administration; people who believe that history repeats itself.

Not Recommended For: people who enjoyed the film for its action and explosions; neo-cons.

Supermarket #1 (of 4)

Premise: No money, mo' problems...

There's a lot to love about Supermarket. First off, the setting is completely original: a nightmarish near-future where consumerism runs rampant. The artist known only as Kristian manages to make the brightly-lit suburbs seem melancholy and alien.
Next, the protagonist: Pella, an affluent teenage girl who's life changes forever by the end of this issue. Writer Brian Wood has created a fully-realized character that could have easily become a caricature (she is part "trust-fund commie", part spoiled brat, but never veers too far in either direction to become unsympathetic).
Finally, the twist. I don't want to talk too much about it (and there are a few interviews where it has been spoiled; Google those if you want), but at the end of the first issue, I could not wait to find out how the hell Pella is going to get out of this situation.

Click the cover to read the first five pages online:



Recommended For: fans of Blade Runner, American Beauty, and/or Heathers; Socialists; people who know all the words to Bob Dylan's "Like A Rolling Stone".
Not Recommended For: economics majors; the well-to-do.

Fallen Angel

Premise: A mysterious woman protects innocents from being preyed on by the dark forces that inhabit a shadowy city.

Acclaimed writer Peter David blends elements of film noir, southern gothic, spaghetti westerns, Voodoo, and Kabbalah and ties them together in one of the most unique and atmospheric comics on the sheves. He paints a vivid picture of life in the city of Bete Noire, a city that seemingly becomes Hell when the sun goes down. He also creates an enduriong heroine in the form of Lee, a literal "fallen angel" who can be as cruel as the monsters she fights at times.

This series was cancelled by DC a while ago, but has recently been restarted by IDW publishing (as of this writing, two issues have been published).



Recommended for: fans of Raymond Chandler, Anne Rice, the Angel televison series, or Supergirl comics.
Not recommended for: people who prefer more clear-cut divisions between hero and villain

Revolution on the Planet of The Apes #1

Premise: Last night, the apes took over San Diego. Is America next?


This six-issue miniseries takes place between the fourth and fifth films in the Planet of the Apes series (Conquest of... and Battle for..., respectively). The story by Joe O'Brien and Ty Templeton is very much in the spirit of the movies and is packed with social and political commentary. Salgood Sam's art is uneven, but it is very much in keeping with the cold, sterile art design of the fourth film. The backup story by Templeton and Attilla, which introduces the antagonist of the miniseries, is excellent. And for people who haven't seen the movies, the first few pages contain a timeline that sums up the events of the first four films.

Recommended for: Fans of the Planet of the Apes films; people who like political allegory in their science fiction.
Not recommended for: people who absolutely refuse to take stories with talking monkeys seriously.

Birth of A Nation

Premise: What would happen if East St. Louis decided to secede from the United States of America?

This is a scathingly funny and thought-provoking graphic novel that skewers race relations, foreign policy, and the fractious nature of the African-American community. It asks tough questions and does not provide easy answers. Filmmaker Reginald Hudlin ("House Party", "Boomerang" ) drew upon his experiences growing up in East St. Louis while co-writing this book with "Boondocks" creator and noted raconteur Aaron McGruder. The infinitely talented Kyle Baker tones down his exaggerated style a notch and delivers some of the best art of his career.



Recommended for: Fans of The Boondocks or The Daily Show.
Not Recommended for: habitual listeners of conservative talk radio.

We'll call it a Holiday vacation...

My computer died a few weeks ago, and my access to the net has been limited, so the updates haven't been as regular as I'd like them to be. I apologize and will update when I can.

Autobiographix

This graphic novel features numerous comic-book creators telling personal anecdotes, ranging from the humorous (legendary cartoonist Sergio Aragones illustrates the time he met Richard Nixon), to the unsettling (Fabio Moon and Gabriel Ba recall an encounter with a gang during their trip to Paris). Some of the stories are poignant (revered creator Will Eisner talks about his first professional rejection), some are cute (Bill Morrison's remembers his childhood obsession with Batman), and some are educational (Matt Wagner depicts his method of making Chicken Parmesan); but all of them are entertaining, and make for a fascinating look into the minds of various comic-book creators.

(This book was originally published in 2003. A sequel is forthcoming; check here for details.)

Recommended For: people who enjoy hearing people tell personal anecdotes at parties; people who listen to the audio commentaries or watch the "making-of" featurettes on DVDs.

Not Recommended For: people who read comics purely for their escapism value.

Fables vol. 1 - "Legends in Exile"

Premise: After being forcibly driven from their homeland, various characters from classic fairy tales adjust to their new lives in modern-day New York.

Fables is an excellent gateway comic because everyone already knows the main characters. Just about everyone has heard of Snow White, Prince Charming, and the Big Bad Wolf. Of course, they may be a little surprised to find that Snow White has become a cynical workaholic, Prince Charming is a philanderer with three failed marriages (to Snow, Sleeping Beauty, and Cinderella) under his belt, and that the Big Bad Wolf is now the sheriff of Fabletown (the neighborhood where all of the fables secretly live among the normals).

Writer Bill Willingham has put together an imaginative series that speaks to the reader's inner child and jaded, embittered adult simultaneously. Pencillers Lan Medina and Mark Buckingham (among others) render a world that is equally magical and grounded in reality. And the painted covers by James Jean are simply stunning (DC/Vertigo were wise to include them in each volume).

Recommended for: anyone who ever had fairy tales read to them as a child; fans of Into The Woods, Confessions of an Ugly Stepsister, and/or Wicked.
Not recommended for: people who only know these characters from their Disney cartoons.

Marvel Team-Up #14

Premise: Invincible is accidentally transported into the Marvel Universe and lands in the middle of a fight between Spider-Man and Dr. Octopus. Hilarity ensues.

There are numerous reasons for me to recommend this issue:

1. It is accessible to new readers.
   
2. It is literally an all-ages comic (wholesome enough for kids, but witty and engaging enough for adults).
3. It will hopefully introduce Invincible (the most interesting new hero to come along in a long time) to a wider audience.
   
4. It is laugh-out-loud funny.
   

It came out in comics stores last week (check the sidebar to find one in your area), and should be available in bookstores next week.

Day of Vengeance

Premise: Can a band of second-string mystical heroes prevent two spirits of vengeance from wiping magic from the face of the Earth?

In a previous post, I talked a little bit about Infinite Crisis. To further fuel the spark of interest among comics fans, DC published four miniseries which would help to set the events of Infinite Crisis into motion, but could be appreciated on their own merits. One of the series was called Day of Vengeance.

The story itself is a good one. Writer Bill Willingham does an excellent job of putting the readers inside the heads of some obscure heroes as they embark on what feels like a suicide mission, and he gets bonus points for making a silly character like Detective Chimp relevant to a modern audience. Penciller Justianino is equally adept at rendering both large-scale battles (two giant characters fighting over the city) and small scale scenes (a dingy other-dimensional tavern, a suburban, middle class home). If this book consisted of only the story, I would heartily recommend it.

Much like a special-edition DVD, the extras are where this book really shines. In addition to the story, the book includes the covers from the original comics, some pages from Justianino's sketchbook, text pieces that introduce the backstory and the heroes to new readers, and a bonus story reprinted from the Superman comics. This story (written by Judd Winick and pencilled by Ian Churchill) helps to establish one of the villains of Day of Vengeance and features an extended fistfight between Superman and Captain Marvel (Shazam!), which is always fun.

Recommended for: fans of Buffy, Lord of the Rings, and/or The Seven Samurai; people who always root for the underdog.

Not recommended for: people who absolutely refuse to take any story with a talking chimp seriously.